Hand-rolled bagels
Bagels are rolled by hand using traditional methods.
Gotham Bagels
Compiled from public sources
Unclaimed business
Unclaimed
- Claim to manage details & reply to reviews
- Pro profile & priority placement
- Reedleys Recognition & certificate
About Gotham Bagels
This is a bagel shop. Gotham Bagels makes New York-style bagels by hand, using traditional ingredients and methods. Each bagel is rolled by hand, kettle boiled, and baked fresh every morning. The shop also serves sandwiches with distinctive flavor combinations and seasonally fresh ingredients, along with coffee. Customers can order bagels online, and catering platters are available for occasions that need more than a dozen bagels. Gotham Bagels began in 2006, founded by a New Yorker seeking to bring traditional New York-style bagels to the Midwest. The business has locations in Madison, Chicago, and Lake Geneva. Its approach draws on bagel-making techniques passed down through generations, with particular attention to ingredient selection and the preparation process.
Disclosure: Profile information has been compiled from publicly available sources and has not yet been verified by the business.
Representative photos. Illustrative images for this category, not photos of Gotham Bagels and not provided by the business.
Services & specialities
Highlights
Fresh every morning
Bagels are kettle boiled and baked fresh each morning.
Catering platters
Platters are available for occasions needing more than a dozen bagels.
Gotham Bagels Reviews
No reviews yet — be the first to review Gotham Bagels.
Write a review
Sign in to write a review
or get a one-click link by email
No password needed. We only use your email to confirm the review is genuine.